2020 was a year of big hikes for me! I decided to finally find the ultimate hiking shoe. My old boots were worn out, and I knew I needed something supportive and comfortable for all my adventures. I spent months researching, reading reviews, and most importantly, testing out different options on various trails. This quest led me to some amazing discoveries, and some less-than-stellar experiences. Prepare to hear all about it!
The Search Begins⁚ Sizing Up My Needs
Before I even considered a single shoe, I knew I needed a solid plan. My hiking style is pretty varied; I tackle everything from gentle nature walks with my dog, Luna, to challenging day hikes in the mountains. This meant my ideal shoe needed to be versatile. I spent weeks meticulously analyzing my needs. Firstly, ankle support was paramount. I’ve had ankle issues in the past, so stability was non-negotiable. Secondly, comfort was key. I’m on my feet for hours, sometimes in uneven terrain, so blister prevention and overall cushioning were crucial. Thirdly, I wanted something lightweight yet durable. I hate lugging around heavy boots, but I also needed something that could withstand rocky trails and occasional stream crossings. Waterproofness was also a significant factor, given my unpredictable hiking locations. Finally, I considered the aesthetic aspect – I wanted a shoe that looked good, too! It sounds superficial, but let’s be honest, style matters! I started making lists, comparing features, and reading countless online reviews. I even consulted with experienced hikers at my local outdoor store, talking to them for hours about their experiences with various brands and models. Their advice was invaluable, helping me narrow down my options considerably. This research phase was surprisingly time-consuming but ultimately essential. It allowed me to approach the testing phase with a clear understanding of my requirements and expectations, ensuring I wouldn’t waste time on unsuitable options. This methodical approach was crucial in my quest to find the perfect hiking shoe.
Testing the Salomon X Ultra 4 GTX
The Salomon X Ultra 4 GTX was one of the first pairs I tested. I’d read rave reviews, and its reputation for comfort and stability intrigued me. I ordered them online, choosing a half-size up based on other users’ recommendations. The first impression was positive; they felt lightweight yet supportive, and the Gore-Tex lining promised waterproof protection – a must-have for my unpredictable British weather. I took them on a series of hikes, starting with shorter, less challenging trails around my home in the Cotswolds. The fit was generally comfortable, though I did notice a slight pressure point on the outside of my right foot after a few hours of walking. However, this wasn’t a deal-breaker. I then pushed the Salomons to their limits on a more challenging hike in the Peak District, tackling steep inclines and uneven terrain. Here, the shoe’s stability really shone. My ankles felt secure, and the Contagrip outsole provided excellent grip, even on wet rocks. The waterproof membrane worked flawlessly, keeping my feet dry despite several stream crossings. However, after several hours, the slight pressure point on my right foot became more pronounced, leading to mild discomfort. While the Salomon X Ultra 4 GTX performed admirably in terms of stability, grip, and waterproofing, the persistent pressure point ultimately disqualified them from my top contender list. The slight discomfort, even after breaking them in, proved too much for long hikes. It’s a shame, as they were otherwise a fantastic shoe. It highlighted the importance of finding the perfect fit, even for well-regarded brands. I learned that even the best reviews can’t fully replace the experience of wearing a shoe for extended periods on various terrains.
My Experience with the Keen Targhee III
After my experience with the Salomons, I turned my attention to the Keen Targhee III. These were recommended by a friend, Eleanor, an avid hiker with a similar foot shape to mine. She raved about their comfort and durability. Intrigued, I ordered a pair, sticking with my usual size this time. Right from the start, the Keen Targhee III felt different. The wider toe box offered significantly more room than the Salomons, immediately alleviating the pressure point issue I’d experienced. They felt more substantial, almost like wearing supportive slippers, but without sacrificing agility. I took them on a variety of hikes, from gentle woodland walks to more challenging climbs in the Lake District. The cushioning was exceptional, absorbing shock effectively, even on rocky terrain. My feet felt protected and comfortable, even after hours of walking. The grip was also very good, though not quite as aggressive as the Salomons on particularly wet surfaces. However, the improved comfort far outweighed this minor drawback. I particularly appreciated the Keen’s breathability; even on warmer days, my feet stayed relatively cool and dry; The only minor downside was the slightly heavier weight compared to the Salomons, but this was easily offset by the enhanced comfort and support. The Keen Targhee III proved to be an excellent all-rounder, a comfortable and reliable shoe suitable for a wide range of hiking conditions. They didn’t quite reach the pinnacle of performance in every aspect, but their overall comfort and durability made them a strong contender in my quest for the perfect hiking shoe. Eleanor’s recommendation proved invaluable; sometimes, personal recommendations are more helpful than online reviews.
The Hoka Speedgoat 4⁚ A Trail Runner’s Delight
By this point in my quest, I was feeling confident in my ability to assess a hiking shoe’s strengths and weaknesses. My next target⁚ the Hoka Speedgoat 4. These had garnered significant attention online, praised for their exceptional cushioning and aggressive tread. Intrigued by the hype, and eager to experience the famed Hoka cushioning, I ordered a pair. The first thing I noticed was the maximalist design; these shoes are undeniably chunky. However, this bulk translated into impressive cushioning. I felt like I was walking on clouds! The Vibram Megagrip outsole provided phenomenal traction, even on loose, muddy trails where I previously struggled for grip. I took them on a particularly challenging hike up Scafell Pike, the highest mountain in England. The steep ascents and descents were significantly easier with the Speedgoat 4’s superior cushioning and grip. My knees felt much less stressed compared to previous hikes. The wide toe box, similar to the Keens, accommodated my feet perfectly, preventing any pressure points. However, the substantial cushioning, while incredibly comfortable, did make the Speedgoats feel less agile than the other shoes I tested. They were a little less responsive for nimble footwork on uneven terrain. This wasn’t a major issue for me, but it’s something to consider if you prioritize agility. The breathability was also slightly less impressive than the Keens, but still adequate for most conditions. Overall, the Hoka Speedgoat 4 exceeded my expectations in terms of cushioning and grip. They were a revelation for tackling challenging trails, offering unparalleled comfort and protection. However, their bulk and slightly reduced agility made them less ideal for shorter, less demanding hikes. They were a fantastic choice for longer, more challenging adventures, but not necessarily an all-around winner like the Keens.
The Verdict⁚ My 2020 Hiking Shoe Champion
After putting the Salomon X Ultra 4 GTX, the Keen Targhee III, and the Hoka Speedgoat 4 through their paces on various terrains and during different types of hikes, it was time to crown a champion. This wasn’t an easy decision; each shoe excelled in certain areas. The Saloman’s waterproof capabilities were undeniably useful during unexpected downpours, but its slightly less comfortable fit held it back. The Hoka Speedgoat 4’s incredible cushioning and grip were perfect for challenging, long-distance hikes, but they felt a little less versatile for shorter, less intense adventures. Ultimately, the Keen Targhee III emerged as my 2020 hiking shoe champion. Its balance of comfort, support, durability, and versatility proved to be unbeatable. The wide toe box ensured my feet never felt cramped, even after hours of hiking. The supportive midsole provided excellent stability on uneven terrain, while the grippy outsole offered reliable traction on various surfaces. I appreciated the breathability, which kept my feet comfortable even on warmer days. Furthermore, the Targhee III’s overall build quality felt exceptionally robust, suggesting a long lifespan. They were consistently comfortable, whether I was tackling a challenging mountain ascent or a leisurely stroll through a forest. I found them equally suitable for both short and long hikes. While the Hoka Speedgoats provided superior cushioning for long distances, the Keens offered a more well-rounded and consistently comfortable experience across a broader range of hiking scenarios. For me, the Keen Targhee III represented the perfect blend of comfort, support, and durability, making it the clear winner in my quest for the perfect hiking shoe in 2020. They became my trusty companions on countless adventures, proving their worth time and time again. I highly recommend them to anyone seeking a reliable and comfortable hiking shoe.
Final Thoughts and Recommendations for 2020 Hikers
Looking back on my 2020 hiking shoe odyssey, I learned a lot about what makes a truly great hiking shoe. It’s not just about the brand name or the price tag; it’s about finding the perfect fit and features for your individual needs and hiking style. For me, that meant prioritizing comfort, support, and durability above all else. I discovered that what works for one person might not work for another. Before investing in a new pair of hiking shoes, I strongly recommend trying them on in person, if possible, and walking around in them for a while to get a feel for the fit. Pay close attention to the toe box, the arch support, and the overall comfort level. Consider the types of terrain you’ll be hiking on most frequently. If you anticipate tackling challenging trails with lots of uneven surfaces, you might prioritize a shoe with robust cushioning and a grippy outsole. If you’ll be hiking in wet conditions, waterproofing is a must. My personal experience highlighted the importance of considering versatility. A shoe that excels on long, challenging hikes might not be the best choice for shorter, less demanding adventures. Ultimately, the best hiking shoe for you is the one that consistently provides comfort, support, and protection, allowing you to focus on enjoying the journey. Don’t be afraid to experiment and try out different models before settling on your perfect pair. Remember to take your time, carefully consider your needs, and above all, enjoy the process of finding your ideal hiking companion. Happy trails!